UK GAAP & IFRS3

IFRS 3 vs UK GAAP (FRS 102): how goodwill treatment differs

IFRS 3 vs UK GAAP (FRS 102): how goodwill treatment differs

Jack Wootton, FCA

Two frameworks, two answers on the same deal

Many UK groups report under IFRS at group level while their UK subsidiaries report under UK GAAP, usually FRS 102. The same acquisition can then produce different goodwill numbers in different sets of consolidated accounts.

Under IFRS

Goodwill is not amortised. It is tested for impairment at least annually under IAS 36, and an impairment loss on goodwill cannot be reversed.

Under UK GAAP (FRS 102)

Goodwill has a finite useful life and is amortised on a systematic basis over it. Where a reliable estimate of that life can’t be made, which FRS 102 treats as exceptional, it can’t exceed ten years. In practice a reliable estimate is hard to make and many groups settle on ten years, but FRS 102 requires the reasons for the period chosen to be disclosed. Impairment follows Section 27, and a goodwill impairment loss cannot be reversed under FRS 102 either.

Goodwill is usually higher under FRS 102 than under IFRS 3. FRS 102 only requires an intangible to be recognised separately from goodwill if it arises from contractual or other legal rights and is separable, so items such as customer relationships typically stay in goodwill. IFRS 3 recognises all identifiable intangibles separately.

UK GAAP is an umbrella term for several frameworks, and this article covers FRS 102, the main standard for UK companies. An entity applying FRS 101 uses IFRS recognition and measurement, so goodwill is not amortised there.

Why this matters for groups

  • Profit: amortisation of goodwill reduces operating profit under UK GAAP (FRS 102) and does not under IFRS. It sits below EBITDA, so EBITDA is unaffected, but EBIT and any covenant defined on it will differ.

  • Reconciliation: a group that has more than one consolidation point may prepare both IFRS and UK GAAP group accounts, so the same acquisition ends up with two goodwill balances at two different consolidation levels that must reconcile.

  • Target's policies: accounting policy differences at the target, such as how development costs are treated, change the net assets acquired and therefore goodwill.

What to settle at deal stage

Decide on day one which framework governs each entity and each consolidation point, whether the target will align to the group framework and when, and how you will track goodwill at each level. Settling it at completion costs a conversation. Finding the mismatch at the first audit costs time that you don't have, and audit fees.

Intanga handles IFRS 3 and FRS 102 acquisition accounting in one platform and helps bridge the two at different consolidation levels of your group.

Be first to use Intanga

Finance Insight for Growth Ltd, company number 12390411. Registered office: 128 City Road, London, EC1V 2NX.

Finance Insight for Growth Ltd, company number 12390411. Registered office: 128 City Road, London, EC1V 2NX.

Finance Insight for Growth Ltd, company number 12390411. Registered office: 128 City Road, London, EC1V 2NX.